Growth & Marketing

E-Commerce Community & Loyalty

We support our clients' customer retention programs in ways big and small, but two of the heavyweights are community and loyalty programs. They work differently, they require different resources, and they attract different types of customer engagement — but both serve the same goal: keeping good customers close.

Community Programs

Community is one of the buzziest ideas in DTC right now, and for good reason. Building a space where your customers can talk to each other — and where your brand can participate in those conversations — creates a kind of loyalty that no points program can replicate. The customers who show up in your community tend to be your best customers: highest LTV, most likely to refer others, most forgiving of the occasional operational hiccup.

We've supported clients in building content-first communities and chat-forward ones. The platforms we work with include Facebook Groups (still the highest-reach option for many brands), Circle and Mighty Networks (for more structured community experiences), and Vanilla Forums (for brands that want a traditional forum format). In each case, we help with platform selection, onboarding strategy, moderation frameworks, and the content cadence that keeps communities active rather than dormant. A community that isn't tended becomes a ghost town fast — we help you avoid that.

Loyalty Programs

Loyalty programs have a reputation for being a tax on topline revenue — you're giving margin back to customers who would have bought anyway. That critique has some truth to it, badly designed loyalty programs can be money pits. But well-designed programs consistently increase purchase frequency, raise average order value, and generate referrals that bring in new customers at zero acquisition cost.

Our preferred platforms are Smile.io and LoyaltyLion — both offer points-for-purchase, birthday rewards, referral modules, and VIP tiers that let you reward your best customers differently than casual buyers. We help with program design (what behaviors to reward and at what rate), implementation and Klaviyo integration, and the ongoing optimization that keeps programs performing.

Used together, community and loyalty create a flywheel: loyal customers become community members, community members become brand advocates, and brand advocates bring in new customers who become loyal. It's a virtuous cycle, and we'd love to help you build it.

No items found.
No items found.
large bright blue hand drawn quotation marks

We use a loyalty system so that consumers can get credits like frequent flyer miles for their purchases. First Pier were the ones to seek out and acquire the necessary apps that get bolted on to Shopify — and it works.

—Patrick Carroll, VP of Innovation, Jasper Wyman & Son

Three people collaborating at a coffee shop with laptop and exposed brick wall